冬季花园剧院

冬季花园剧院(纽约市)

冬季花园剧院
4.5
星期日
上午12:15 - 上午12:30
来自旅行者的点评
Projournalist
作者:Projournalist
A wonderful show, but key cast members don't reach the high mark in this revival
2022年5月
我对我们在百老汇冬季花园剧院看到的梅雷迪思·威尔逊的《音乐人》的 2022 年复兴的看法。 (我在百老汇和 1962 年的电影版都看过原版,两者都由罗伯特·普雷斯顿饰演“教授”和骗子哈罗德·希尔。) 2022 年的复兴由非常受欢迎的演员休·杰克曼主演;但他不是罗伯特·普雷斯顿。它还主演了萨顿福斯特,我们在其他环境中欣赏过他的歌声,作为图书管理员玛丽安帕鲁;但她也不是芭芭拉库克或雪莉琼斯。 在我看来,2022 年复兴的明星是编舞(沃伦·卡莱尔(Warren Carlyle)),特别是对火车上(“岩岛”,与原版节目非常相似)和图书馆(“玛丽安,图书管理员 ” ) 。星光舞为市长 Shinn 的女儿 Zaneeta (Emma Crow) 和她的男朋友 Tommy (Gina Cosculluela) 鼓掌,音乐人是他们的百老汇处女作。年轻演员本杰明·帕贾克 (Benjamin Pajak) 也让他在百老汇的处子秀大吃一惊,他扮演温思罗普·帕鲁 (Winthrop Paroo),口齿不清。 不要误会我的意思:《音乐人》仍然是一部精彩的演出,它怀念像我们这样年长的剧院观众,但也是对年轻人了解百老汇音乐流派的精彩介绍。音乐和歌词仍然巧妙而令人难忘,布景很棒(特别向“富国银行”和“图书管理员玛丽安”致敬)。 但是复兴的音乐方向迫使该节目的智能歌曲进入太快的节奏;有好几次,杰克曼和萨顿似乎都在匆匆写歌词以跟上管弦乐队的节奏。萨顿的声音优美、有力、清晰,但除了少数例外,她的表演并没有用重要的视觉情感丰富音乐(在“钢琴课/晚安我的人”和“我的白夜”中很明显)。平心而论,萨顿的表演确实取得了一些特殊的时刻,尤其是在第二幕中,她(最终)爱上了希尔。 而杰克曼只是没有时间技巧来配合他的声音以获得最大的喜剧效果(这在超级明星数字中尤其明显,例如“Ya Got Trouble”和“Sadder But Wiser Girl”)。 (显然,罗伯特·普雷斯顿(Robert Preston)不像演员那样是歌手,这可能是他在希尔这个角色上如此成功的原因。) 复兴精彩地再现了原作的其他亮点:理发店号码、“Pick-a-Little”女士和“Shipoopi”。 但是舒勒·亨斯利选择扮演希尔的骗子搭档马塞勒斯几乎是一场灾难。汉斯利的诠释缺乏电影版中巴迪·哈克特曾经为这个角色带来的任何火花。可悲的是,对我来说,演出结束时“七十六号长号”那闪闪发光的大音乐渐强也落空了。穿着制服的演员不够多(而且制服似乎有点破旧),而编排似乎已经“爵士乐”以使其更现代(或其他什么)。 总的来说,我推荐复兴;这仍然是一种刺激。只需控制您的期望即可。

建议修改以优化页面内容。
完善此详情页
游览和体验
探索体验此地点的不同方式。

体验“冬季花园剧院”和附近景点的最佳方式

区域
地址
区域: 剧院区
如何到达
  • 50th St • 步行 1 分钟
  • 49th St • 步行 2 分钟

4.5
220 条点评
极佳
134
非常好
66
一般
11
较差
6
很糟糕
3

Projournalist
Delaware426 条分享
2022年5月
My thoughts on the 2022 revival of Meredith Wilson's "The Music Man" which we saw at the Winter Garden Theatre on Broadway. (I had seen the original, both on Broadway and the 1962 film version, both of which starred Robert Preston as "Professor" and con man Harold Hill.)

The 2022 revival stars Hugh Jackman, a hugely popular actor; but he's no Robert Preston. It also stars Sutton Foster, whose singing we have enjoyed in other settings, as librarian Marian Paroo; but she, too, is no Barbara Cook or Shirley Jones.

In my opinion, the star of the 2022 revival is the choreography (by Warren Carlyle), with special bravos to the ensemble numbers on the train ("Rock Island," very similar to the original show) and in the library ("Marian, the Librarian"). Star-turn dance applause to Mayor Shinn's daughter Zaneeta (Emma Crow) and her boyfriend Tommy (Gina Cosculluela), for whom The Music Man is their Broadway debut. Also knocking the socks off his Broadway debut is young actor Benjamin Pajak, who plays Winthrop Paroo, with his lisp.

Don't get me wrong: The Music Man is still a great show, nostalgic for older theater goers like us, but also a wonderful introduction for young people to the Broadway musical genre. The music and lyrics are still clever and memorable, the sets are great (special tips of the hat to "Wells Fargo Wagon" and "Marian the Librarian" in this revival).

But the revival's musical direction forces the show's smart songs into a too-rapid pace; on several occasions, Jackman and Sutton seem to be rushing through their lyrics to keep up with the orchestra. Sutton's voice is beautiful, strong and clear, but with a few exceptions, her acting doesn't enrich the music with important visual emotion (niticeable in "Piano Lesson/Good Night My Someone" and "My White Night"). In fairness, Sutton does achieve a few special moments with her acting, especially in Act Two when she's (finally) falling for Hill.

And Jackman just doesn't have the timing skills to couple with his voice for maximum comedic effect (this is exposed especially in superstar numbers like "Ya Got Trouble" and "Sadder But Wiser Girl"). (Apparently Robert Preston wasn't as much of a singer as he was an actor, which may be why he succeeded so well in the role of Hill.)

The revival wonderfully reprises other highlights of the original: the barbershop numbers, the "Pick-a-Little" ladies, and "Shipoopi."

But the choice of Shuler Hensley to play Hill's con man sidekick Marcellus is a near disaster; Hensley's interpretation lacks any of the spark once brought to the role by Buddy Hackett in the film version. And sadly, for me, the big gleaming musical crescendo of "Seventy-Six Trombones" at the show's conclusion fell flat, too. Not enough actors in uniform (and the uniforms seemed a little threadbare), and the orchestration seemed to have been "jazzed" to make it more contemporary (or something).

Overall, I recommend the revival; it's still a thrill. Just keep your expectations in check.
撰写日期:2022年5月14日
此点评为 Tripadvisor 会员所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。

Jonathan Chan
纽约州纽约市214 条分享
2022年4月
We watched The Music Man at the Winter Garden Theatre! The show was warm-hearted and fun, and the theatre is designed so that all of the seats offer a great view!
撰写日期:2022年4月8日
此点评为 Tripadvisor 会员所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。

crunch6
伊利诺伊州诺斯布鲁克627 条分享
2022年2月
Loved our Mezzanine experience to see THE MUSIC MAN!!!!! Bravo! The theater is so small and manageable. No matter what seat you choose, you will have a great seat and great views....even the $99 seats in the Mezz!
撰写日期:2022年3月2日
此点评为 Tripadvisor 会员所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。

mwooduk
佛罗里达迈阿密7,575 条分享
2022年3月 • 夫妻情侣
My husband and I flew from Miami to New York last week so that I could finally see Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster in The Music Man at the Winter Garden - I had waited 2 1/2 years since buying the tickets to see the show and it did not disappoint. You have to have your CDC card and ID as well as your ticket to get into the theater. All the staff were very nice, the exception being the stupid man walking around with a sign that says Masks Up. I understand that masks are required in New York theaters at the moment but he treated us like children, the one time mine slipped a quarter of an inch below my nose after having blown my nose, he came right up to me and told me very grimly to lift it back up again. Very OTT in my opinion. The show itself was fabulous, the sound was great, the seats were comfortable and the theatre is beautiful. Hugh and Sutton were amazing as was the whole cast and I highly recommend the show if you are looking for an enjoyable and uplifting night out!
撰写日期:2022年3月2日
此点评为 Tripadvisor 会员所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。

Jeremy L
德克萨斯州葡萄藤335 条分享
2022年1月 • 夫妻情侣
My first time to a Broadway show and it was exceptional. This theatre is really cool and intimate. Comfortable, great views from any seat.

Staff was friendly inside and outside the theatre ushering folks to seats.

If I had any complaint it was too warm in the theatre but that’s probably because it was 10 degrees outside. So you can be confident the heat works!

Would have preferred some con sessions to be open during intermission but again that’s a small thing.

Would definitely go back to the theatre and if you get a chance to see Music Man you must go!
撰写日期:2022年1月20日
此点评为 Tripadvisor 会员所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。

nmarcum03
西维吉尼亚查尔斯顿462 条分享
2020年3月 • 家庭
Took our girls (ages 11 & 13) to go see Beetlejuice! Absolutely amazing time and made the whole trip to NYC worth it!! Only complaint is Beetlejuice leaving this theatre 😭. Can't wait to see the show again!
撰写日期:2020年3月5日
此点评为 Tripadvisor 会员所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。
Hello! Happy to hear you enjoyed your visit to the Winter Garden Theatre. We appreciate your patronage and look forward to seeing you again soon. Sincerely, Theatre Operations
撰写日期:2020年3月11日
此回复为企业代表所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。

Kelli
德克萨斯州Keller646 条分享
2020年1月 • 好友
Everyone talking about cramped seats must have never been to other theatres on Broadway! This theatre is one of the few with any kind of leg room and without the seat arm rests digging into my body. The restrooms are on the orchestra/entry level, which is rare on broadway as well and super appreciated. We saw Beetlejuice here and the show was phenomenal.
撰写日期:2020年2月13日
此点评为 Tripadvisor 会员所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。

cindystratton1972
乔治亚纽南55 条分享
2020年1月 • 好友
Beetle juice was my 3rd show seen in this theatre. More seat and leg room than others and heating was very comfortable .
撰写日期:2020年2月11日
此点评为 Tripadvisor 会员所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。

Fuzzy K
加利福尼亚莱克福里斯特92 条分享
2020年2月
This theatre has been around forever. I have seen shows there, including Beetlejuice earlier this week. Not a bad seat in the house. This time I sat at the far right side of the back of the orchestra section, and the view was fine. I would do it again.

The only warning I would give is that it's really hard to get to the bathrooms on breaks. The hall area is very small for so many people, and the theatre has mastered a winding line managed by the staff.
撰写日期:2020年2月8日
此点评为 Tripadvisor 会员所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。

michaelwillie68
纽约州布鲁克林28 条分享
2020年1月 • 家庭
Great play, but ushers were terrible!! The play was outstanding, but the ushers didn’t assist people getting to their assigned seats, so in the middle of the show a complete row had to be moved and disrupted all of us in the row!
撰写日期:2020年2月2日
此点评为 Tripadvisor 会员所写的主观评论,并不代表 TripAdvisor LLC 的观点。

显示第 110 页的结果,共 220
信息遗漏或有误?
建议修改以优化页面内容。
完善此详情页
关于冬季花园剧院的常见问题

冬季花园剧院开放中:
  • 日 - 日 上午12:15 - 上午12:30
通过 Tripadvisor 提前买票。 如果通过 Tripadvisor 预订,最迟可在游览开始日期前 24 小时取消预订并获得全额退款。

我们建议您提前预订冬季花园剧院游览以预留名额。 如果通过 Tripadvisor 预订,最迟可在游览开始前 24 小时取消预订并获得全额退款。 查看 Tripadvisor 上全部 2 个冬季花园剧院游览

冬季花园剧院附近的酒店: 在 Tripadvisor 上查看冬季花园剧院附近的所有酒店

冬季花园剧院附近的餐厅: 在 Tripadvisor 上查看冬季花园剧院附近的所有餐厅

冬季花园剧院附近的景点: 在 Tripadvisor 上查看冬季花园剧院附近的所有景点